CSRS Employees: Should You Deposit Money to Cover Temporary Federal Employment?
By John Grobe
Sunday, March 30, 2008
CSRS employees often ask themselves the following two questions about civilian service as they get close to retirement. "Should I deposit money to cover temporary time early in my career?" "Should I re-deposit money I withdrew from my retirement when I left government service for a few years?"
This article is about the first of the two questions; whether to make a deposit for temporary time. A future article will discuss the second question for CSRS folks.
FERS employees may occasionally ask themselves the same questions, but this article is not about FERS employees – it is only about CSRS. Another future article will discuss these issues for FERS folks.
Not to keep you in suspense, the general answer is "it depends."
HR folks refer to this as ‘deposit service'. That is service, usually early in your career, where CSRS retirement deductions were not taken from your pay. This service might have been as a seasonal postal worker when in college (mine was), or time spent in some types of temporary employment. At that time there was no expectation on your part, or on the government's part for that matter, that you would sometime later become a federal employee who would ultimately retire from federal service.
If your ‘deposit service' ended prior to 10/01/82, the service will count towards your eligibility to retire and will count towards the computation of your annuity, regardless of whether or not you make a deposit. However, if you don't make a deposit, your annuity is reduced by 10% of the amount you owe, both deposit and interest. Interest is charged at 3% per year.
Here's an example:
Paul was a seasonal letter carrier in Secaucus, New Jersey for three months in the summer of 1982. He earned $2400.00 during that period of time and CSRS deductions were not withheld from his salary. Had they been withheld, they would have totaled $168.00 (7% of $2400.00). With interest at 3%, we are looking at an amount of roughly $356.00 today. If Paul did not pay the deposit, his annual annuity would be reduced by $35.60 per year or slightly less than 3 bucks a month.
If we were to totally disregard opportunity cost (what we could make by investing the $356), Paul would recoup his $356 in ten years. Paul wouldn't be missing a lot whether or not he made the payment.
Now let's say that Paul had his three months of temporary service in the summer of 1983. The service would be creditable for his eligibility to retire, but it would not be counted in the computation of his annuity. In addition, variable interest rates would be used to compute the amount he owed. Paul's deposit amount would be roughly $879.00 today.
If Paul did not make the deposit, the three months of service represented by the temporary time would not be used to compute his annuity. Let's say Paul will retire with 30 years of service and a high-three salary of $50,000. That would give him an annuity of $28,125 per year. If the three months were not used, has annual annuity would be $27,792. Once again disregarding opportunity cost, Paul would recoup his $879 in less than three years.
It is possible to have more than one period of deposit service, so individual computations may be more difficult than the examples above.
If you're in a situation where you are considering making a deposit to cover temporary service, perhaps your best bet is to contact HR and ask them to compute how much you owe and what effect it will have on your annuity if you make it (or not).
The good news out of this is that, in most cases, the amounts of money we are dealing with are relatively small, and the costs of an uninformed decision are not going to drive you into the poorhouse.
© 2009 John Grobe. All rights reserved. This article may not be reproduced without express written consent from John Grobe.
|
Readers' Comments
Posted: February 14, 2009 10:48 AM
Posted: September 7, 2008 9:35 AM
Posted: July 6, 2008 3:20 PM
View All Comments »