Search:

Custom Search
Photo of Susan Smith

Firing a Government "Volunteer" Isn't Easy

By Susan Smith

Friday, November 4, 2005

You can have daily headlines from FedSmith.com delivered right to your desktop each business morning. The service is free and you don't get junk e-mail as the price of your subscription. Just visit our newsletter page to sign up!

Susan McGuire Smith spent most of her 26-year federal government career with NASA, first at NASA Headquarters Office of General Counsel and then at Marshall Space Flight Center, serving as Chief Counsel there for more than 14 years. Her expertise is in government contracts, ethics, and personnel law. Ms. Smith has a J.D and a B.A. degree from the George Washington University. Her publications include Practical Ethics for the Federal Employee.
A recent decision of the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals concerns availability under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) of a Peace Corps draft Administrative Separation Report (ASR). (Horowitz v. Peace Corps, U.S.C.A.D.C., No. 04-5065, 10/28/05)

Under the Peace Corps Manual, if the agency considers separating a volunteer early, there is a process to follow. The volunteer is to be told of the specific conduct that gave rise to consideration of an early termination, a chance to respond, and given the opportunity to resign before a final decision is made. If the volunteer opts for resignation, then the ASR is not completed and not made part of the agency’s records. But the resignation must occur before the final decision is made to separate; otherwise the ASR is completed.

In this case, the volunteer opted to resign before the ASR was finalized. So the Peace Corps manager did not complete the report and did not forward it to the office of record within the agency. But, at the volunteer’s request the manager kept a copy of the draft report in his safe. The former volunteer requested a copy of the document under the FOIA and the agency declared it covered by exemption 5 and refused to release it. The agency also denied his request for access to the document under the Privacy Act. Finally, the agency refused to disclose the identity of the “alleged victim” of the volunteer’s actions that were the subject of the draft ASR.

The U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia sided with the agency. (No. 00cv00848) The court determined that the agency properly invoked exemption 5 in denying the draft ASR under FOIA. The lower court also found that the draft ASR was not part of a system of records subject to disclosure under the Privacy Act. But the district court did order the agency to disclose the identity of the alleged victim.

The appeals court concluded that the District Court was correct in applying exemption 5 to the document and in its reasoning on application of the Privacy Act. It however disagreed as to disclosure of the identity of the alleged victim of the Peace Corps volunteer’s actions and ruled that the agency had properly refused to disclose that information. The court indicated that the alleged victim’s privacy interest clearly outweighed any public interest in disclosing his identity, calling such interest “virtually nonexistent.” (Opinion p. 11)

© 2010 FedSmith Inc. All rights reserved. This article may not be reproduced without express written consent of FedSmith Inc.

Add a Comment about this Article

** All fields are required.
Note: Your comments will not show up right away. FedSmith.com selects the most insightful comments from our readers for posting. If selected, your comments will show up in the comments section after they have been reviewed and approved. See our terms of use for more information.

Readers' Comments

  • Totally agree with contract specialist's comments. Additionally, even if the person was volunteering at their local Red Cross or any other agency, it does not give them a passport to any behavior. Volunteers are a reflection on the agency with which they volunteer and therefore are subject to the ...
    Posted: November 10, 2005 1:28 PM
  • Obviously he was not interested in defending himself if he resigned before being fired. And, it doesn't sound like there were formal charges filed against him. So what did he have to defend himself from? He can't have it both ways....
    Posted: November 10, 2005 1:24 PM
  • I don't mean to sound rude, but you don't seem to be very well informed about the Peace Corps. Volunteers get food, board, and a small stipend because they are stationed in various countries around the world. The 'volunteer' positions are a 27-month commitment to live in a foreign country, sometim...
    Posted: November 8, 2005 9:13 AM

View All Comments »

MORE BY SUSAN SMITH

Contact Susan Smith or read more articles on the author's page.