Search:

Custom Search

Readers' Comments

Total Comments: 138
Page 1 of 13

« Previous | Next »

Underpaid Feds?

Underpaid Feds?

Records Analyst - Human Resources Assistant
Army Human Resources Command
Mon Aug 7, 2006 9:26 AM

Post Reply

I have been with the Government for eight and a half years and only making 32,130 per year with a degree.
My children work in the public sector and make much more than I do and they get great benefits. My one daughter had her education paid by her employer and they are now paying for her Masters Degree. All included in her benfits. The figures you are talking about are managers who yes, are probably overpaid.

Re: Underpaid Feds?

Just About Retired
USMC
Wed Nov 14, 2007 12:39 PM
I am not a manager. I do not have a college degree. I do have 32+ years of experience. Started as a GS-2 and worked my way up to a GS-12 (back and forth a few times when I was following my military husband). I'm now single, received no money from the marriage, and do just fine. I also have the maximum use or lose and 8 months worth of sick leave (I'm CSRS). I never whinned about my pay, but I did always raise my hand and volunteer for anything and everything. Your job is what you make of it. Make something of it!!! OR, better yet, join your kids in private industry.

Re: Underpaid Feds?

Lets show our pay statements
DOD
Fri Dec 28, 2007 10:22 PM
No one should "Whine" about their pay. If they don't like it do someting about it. Bottom line is there is a ton of money available that should be given to hard working dedicated people. I retired form the military, and NEVER complained about the pay, but if one dod not et promoted despite being a good performer, then you'd hear the moaning from the deckplates! That is how it is.

Proverty Level

Procurement Technician
Defense Contract Management Agency
Mon Aug 7, 2006 9:29 AM

Post Reply

Not sure how Mr. Smith came up with his information on this article, I live in the Silicon Valley and read an article this weekend that place my income level in the proverty level for this area. How could someone say the Federal Employees, make more than private sector employees. Just right here in the company that I reside in as a government employee the fellow coworkers for the company make generally twice plus the average government employee. I think the reasoning and way this information was put together was meant to portray that government workers make that type of money. Really from the workers point of view in the community, it is definitely less.

Re: Proverty Level

HR Specialist
USDA
Mon Aug 7, 2006 10:01 AM
The article is pretty clear that the information is from the Department of Commerce and compiled by a researcher who works for a private "think tank." The "average" for both groups are just that--an average. Regardless of what most of us may think, federal employees are much better off than most American workers who are paying our salaries and benefits. No doubt, many federal employees in high cost areas do not feel like they are rich; there are still millions of Americans who see our average salaries are are hot under the collar when they read how their money is being spent while making much less than most of us make.

Note also that the averages are getting wider apart so the disparity between the federal workforce and the rest of the country is getting further apart. Perhaps we should, as the article states, start thinking of ourselves as Republicans since many of us are in the upper strata of personal income.

Re: Proverty Level

Engineer
Army
Tue Aug 8, 2006 3:17 PM
If the Feds are much better off than the Private Sector why does NSPS and MaxHr need the flexibility to offer recruitment and retention bonuses, as well as pay banding? Is it so that the Govt can artificially hold or put a freeze on salaries until the private sector catches up? Not sure where OPM and Administration see a problem with retention. Data can be manipulated to represent what you want to say. First rule in Statistics 101.

Re: Proverty Level

Procurement Support Assistant (Procurement Technician)
Minerals Management
Wed Sep 27, 2006 9:49 AM
I'm with you right there a poverty level. Unlike employees at DOD I'm paying my own way through college. If I don't get a better job in the next two years I'll have to go back to the private sector.

Fed Pay

IT Specialist
SSA
Mon Aug 7, 2006 9:30 AM

Post Reply

I do not think this analysis was a one-to-one regarding job types. For example, I was a IT professional in the private sector and received yearly bonuses that was over 10% of my salary. Does that account for anything?

I do not agree with this article.....

Auditor
DoD
Mon Aug 7, 2006 9:31 AM

Post Reply

After reading this article, I went to the pay tables and compared the DC area to Pittsburgh and the Rest of the U.S. to see how DC's COLA ranked. When comparing GS 11 salaries, DC is around $54,300, Pittsburgh is $53,500 and the rest of the US is around $51,900. First, Pittsburgh's cost of living is no where near DC's and they're only $1,500 behind. And the rest of the US is only $2,400 behind DC. Something's wrong with that. This is also why DC agencies have a hard time retaining people because why make $54,000 as a GS-11 when you can have the same years of experience and go into the private sector and make $60-something with the same experience. I seriously think the COLA needs to be re-thought. Maybe this is where NSPS would be good....but we won't touch that debate.....

Underpaid Feds?

Logistics
DOD
Mon Aug 7, 2006 9:33 AM

Post Reply

calif is soooo expensensive. we cannot keep up

Re: Underpaid Feds?

Logistics Manager
Navy
Tue Aug 8, 2006 8:22 AM
My wife and I could not afford the American Dream in CA, so we left and are in the DC zone. We are still only able to afford an 1100 sq ft home, a 4-year old, 20k car, and a 7-year old Chevy Suburban. We don't smoke, we don't drink, seldom go out to eat (breakfast, usually), and even as a GS-12 and with a GS-11 retirement, we are still barely making ends meet. And that's outside California, where renting is very often more costly than the exhorbitant mortgages.

Re: Underpaid Feds?

Budget analyst
DOD
Wed Sep 27, 2006 10:42 AM
The only thing soooooooooo expensive in California, where I lived and worked until base closures forced me elsewhere, is real-estate. Try living in the "REST" of the country catagory in ANY other state where for example taxes are outrageous, gas is the highest in the country, excluding Hawaii, including taxes on food.

Re: Underpaid Feds?

Just About Retired
USMC
Wed Nov 14, 2007 12:45 PM
Please, you still have 50 states to choose from. If you left CA thinking DC would be cheaper.......you might have wanted to save that decision for a day when your doctor didn't precribe you any smoke........

I'm in GA and have a 3,000 sq ft home with an inground pool on 3/4 acre. The house only cost me $140,000 two years ago. I left New Orleans because of Katrina and much to my surprise, there is a life after living in the "Big Easy". Now I can afford to have a house in GA and a good time in New Orleans.

Federal vs. private sector pay.

Program Analyst
GSA
Mon Aug 7, 2006 9:37 AM

Post Reply

Remeber that much Federal work has been privatized. In GSA, many lower wage grade positions are now done by contractors, so I thinke our grade pyramid has skewed toward the higher GS positions, less WG's. So it may not be a completely fair comparison unless you include Federal work don by contractors and their employees. Averages can be very deceptive if the underlying data is not analyzed properly.

Looking forward to seeing the stats and sources.

ES
EPA
Mon Aug 7, 2006 9:40 AM

Post Reply

I'd like to see his method, sample, and data. Having working in private and public sectors, I just don't buy it, no matter what the reputation of the Cato Institute.

Total Comments: 138
Page 1 of 13

« Previous | Next »

Add a Comment about this Article

** All fields are required.
Note: Your comments will not show up right away. FedSmith.com selects the most insightful comments from our readers for posting. If selected, your comments will show up in the comments section after they have been reviewed and approved. See our terms of use for more information.